“…in the last decade our fiction writers use only ‘I’…”

March 31, 2012 @ 8:54 am | Filed under: Books

Katharine S. White to Elizabeth Lawrence, March 17, 1960:

Next, I had to wind up a huge job I’ve been working on for six months—The New Yorker stories—1950-1960….The book will be out next fall but it still is not quite settled as to contents, order of stories etc. etc. It is a compromise selection, to suit the taste of five editors. I merely headed up the chore, but Bill Shawn of course has the final word. Most of what we have together is, I think, first rate writing but the trouble is that in the last decade our fiction writers use only “I” and their favorite themes are death, childhood, or the past. It was a jigsaw puzzle to fit it together. The South and Ireland are also in the ascendancy. I love the South but not Ireland (I confess) and I would gladly have cut out a couple of Irish stories but was voted down. My feelings do not apply to Frank O’Connor.

(Yet another quote from Two Gardeners: A Friendship in Letters, edited by Emily Herring Wilson. I’m only halfway through, so I expect there will be more.)

Related:
Two Gardeners: A Rabbit Trail
“I have had to give up writing to my close friends”


    Related Posts

  • I've been making Primer jokes about the iPad ever since it appeared, but this beats all.
    I’ve been making Primer jokes about the iPad ever since it appeared, but this beats all.
  • "Snuggling Up to Genius"
    “Snuggling Up to Genius”
  • Writing for a Living: Q & A
    Writing for a Living: Q & A
  • Ancient Greece: An Incomplete & Rather Hasty Bonny Glen Roundup
    Ancient Greece: An Incomplete & Rather Hasty Bonny Glen Roundup
  • How Cool Is This?
    How Cool Is This?

Comments

3 Responses | | Comments Feed

  1. Do you remember what Jerry and his sister say about books that use ‘I’ in Ginger Pye? Chuckle.

  2. I love your rabbit trail.
    More, more.
    Emily

  3. […] Two Gardeners: A Rabbit Trail “I have had to give up writing to my close friends” “In the last decade our fiction writers use only ‘I’…” […]