Reflecting Upon Nice

September 9, 2007 @ 1:50 pm | Filed under:

I’ve been thinking about being nice.

Wait, that didn’t sound right. I mean, I’ve been thinking about what it means to be nice.

Two very kind blog friends* have given me a Nice Matters Award:  Margaret Mary Myers and Michele Quigley (who knows me by my married name, not just my pen name, as you’ll see on her list). Both of them are awfully nice to have included me among such stellar company. Go look at their lists and you’ll see what I mean. Some of my favorite women on the internet (and in real life!) are included there.


And so of course this got me thinking about whether I’m as nice as those other wonderful women. If someone named me for a Well-Organized Woman award, or a Punctuality award, or a Never Gets Cranky award, I’d have to decline on grounds of honesty (after I picked myself up off the floor from laughing so hard).

But nice? You know, I really do agree with the sentiment behind this award. Nice does matter. Just ask my children; I have been known to holler about not caring whether they grow up to be smart or rich or good-looking as long as they are nice people. "DO YOU HEAR MEEEE??? JUST BE NICE TO EACH OTHER!! BEEE NIIIIIICE!!!!!!!!" (Thus do I qualify myself for the "Do As I Say, Not as I Do" Award. Heh.)

OK, so maybe that’s a lesson better modeled than screeched. I try to be nice, really I do. Sometimes being nice can get complicated, though.

There’s a Carole King song called "Child of Mine" which I’ve loved since Jane was a baby, but there was one line that always bugged me. "I know you will be honest if you can’t always be kind." When I crooned that song to wee Jane, I used to change the lyric to "I know you will be honest, but you also will be kind"—clunky, yes, but it scans.

I’ve been thinking about that line a lot lately, about the sometimes thorny marriage of honesty and kindness. Sometimes being honest doesn’t seem very kind. The kids and I watched an Andy Griffith Show episode the other day, in which the town drunk was turned on to mosaic art by an earnest young deputy, and his newfound passion for making pictures became a magical detox program—until the former drunk presented Andy with a perfectly dreadful picture to hang over the fireplace, and later found out Andy had hidden it in the closet as soon as they guy left.

It would have been kinder of Andy to leave that picture over the mantel, but the truth was he hated looking at it.

Of course the punch line of the episode was that the guy went back on the sauce—and began creating perfectly marvelous mosaics under the influence. But that’s not relevant to my train of thought here. I’ve just been pondering, as I said, what it means to be nice, and where that intersects with honesty.

Sometimes being nice means keeping your opinions to yourself. ("Those are the ugliest shoes I’ve ever seen.")

Sometimes it means speaking up in the face of injustice, even if you have to tell a friend a hard truth.

I guess what "nice" really means is playing fair, which is another way of saying "observe the Golden Rule." Doing unto others as I’d like them to do unto me sometimes means speaking up when there’s a problem. If I’m screwing up or hurting someone, I’d like to be made aware of it (gently), so I can put things right.

As hard as it can be to be the person being corrected, I think it can be even harder to be the one doing the correcting. There’s such an inner wrestling match involved in the process of discerning whether the little voice that urges you to speak out is the voice of conscience (to be obeyed) or pride (to be slapped down). When do you turn the other cheek, and when do you take up a cause?

I guess it depends on whose cheek, whose cause. We’re supposed to turn our own cheek, and seek to right wrongs committed against others. But that’s hard, too, both of those things, for lots of reasons and in lots of ways.

Maybe the lyric should be: "I know you will be honest, and you’ll try darn hard to be kind."

It doesn’t scan, but it speaks more to the point.

Because I do try to be nice, I find it impossible to name other deserving people for the Nice Matters award. There are too, too many of you out there who are far nicer than I am. I fear that if I start naming names, the people I leave out (for lack of space) will be hurt, and that wouldn’t be nice.

Actually, for that very same reason I ditched my blogroll this morning. It was long out of date, and when I started trying to catch it up I realized it was going to be pages and pages long, and still I’d probably miss someone I meant to include. So I scrapped it altogether. There are a few other link lists still lingering in my sidebar, but those, too, are out of date and incomplete. I’ll think about them another day. Sidebars don’t matter so much anymore anyway, now that most blog-readers are subscribed to a feed.

Anyway, Michele and Margaret Mary, thanks so much for the award. I’ll try darn hard to deserve it. I will certainly continue to reflect upon what it means, which I guess means I definitely qualify for the other blog award I was granted recently: the Blogger Reflection Award, compliments of two extremely nice blog friends: Elena and Alice Cantrell.


Thank you both. I do love a nice reflection.

*Make that three! It seems Christine nominated me for the Nice Matters award this very morning, before she read my post! Thank you so much, Christine. So nice!

    Related Posts


11 Reponses | Comments Feed
  1. Jennifer says:

    Well said. I agree, which is why I can’t do memes anymore. I feel like it’s junior high and certain people are chosen over others. I know it’s supposed to be fun, but I always feel like I will hurt someone’s feelings.

  2. Christine M says:

    As luck would have it, I just nominated you for this award (a couple of hours ago).

    As regards the Golden Rule – my son is under the impression that that is the law of the land. As in: “He broke the law – he didn’t do unto others as he would want others to do unto him”. Maybe we’d all be better off it is was the law. heh.

  3. JoVE says:

    Good thoughts. On blog-rolls, I kind of agree but also think they serve a purpose. When I set mine up it was more for me than for others. I used it to keep what I formerly had as bookmarks in a place I could access when i was away from home. And now that I subscribe to feeds, that doesn’t matter.

    But I also know that I have found some very interesting blogs by surfing the blog rolls of those I already enjoy. I don’t do it often, but it can be a good source of things I might not otherwise find.

  4. Margaret in Minnesota says:

    You know, any time you want to come by and reflect over a cup of tea or, say, a can of Dr. Pepper…you’re welcome. Until then I will make do with posts like this one–so very nice, yes, but also so very fun and so insightful.

    Have a blessed week!

  5. Catherine M says:

    I would say that “nice” is helping calm a frantic mother by replying to her email with a long and thoughtful message. That may even be “beyond nice.” Was there an award in that category? Thanks again.

  6. Mary says:

    Beautiful Lissa….

    I’m sending this to my Margaret.
    Ms. Willa will be taking a nice reward to her teacher.


  7. Penny in VT says:

    Great great post Melissa – thanks for sharing your posts – your blog is SUCH a treasure!


  8. Karen Edmisten says:

    Great post, Lissa. I, too, have a post started on a Blogger Reflection and a Nice Matters thing … but I always get meme paralysis exactly because I don’t want to leave anyone out. Then, on the flipside, I don’t want to hurt feelings of people who were kind enough to think of me, so, what’s a trying-to-be-nice blogger to do? 🙂

    Sidebar links are the bane of our existence, too ….

  9. Steve the LLamabutcher says:

    One definition of nice: will you let your kids play with other kids who have recently had/going through the hair critters?

    We ran up into that this summer, with our first trip down hair critter memory lane. What made it doubly fun, it was right as we were leaving on a long-scheduled trip north to see the family. Let me tell ya, that was interesting.

    We followed the bonny glen advice and got the mega-combs, which did the trick quite well.

  10. Jeanne says:

    In my early twenties, I had a troubled co-worker who caused me no end of emotional turmoil. A turning point for me — when I realized the trouble between us was her creation and I just needed to be responsible for my reaction — was when she told me that I “used being nice” to get my way.

    I should hit people over the head with a baseball bat instead?

  11. genevieve says:

    Hi Melissa, I have just popped back to visit to see how your young man is getting on, and found this earnest and honest piece which is right on the noggin today.
    Thanks very much indeed! I’ve been in the position of the last commenter before too – it’s not a ‘nice’ space at all.
    Best wishes to you, this award has found a great home. (PS my kids are big but I still want them to be nice.)