Outlines and without-lines
This photo reminds me that at one point, I had a whole secret theme going on my Instagram. I never told anyone (except Scott, of course) what I was going for, but I kept the project going for months. It wasn’t every photo, just one or two a week, and the theme would have been hard to guess at. It was a look at juxtapositions of color: manmade structures and objects behind or next to objects from nature. Flowers against walls, brilliant red poppies in front of a bright blue recycling bin, lime-green moss next to yellow rain boots, that sort of thing. I remember one of my favorites was a scatter of autumn leaves in a leaf-shaped pothole.
It was fun, having a secret art project. I tend to spill all my artistic secrets out of enthusiasm—sometimes to their detriment. It’s easy to lose steam on a project after I’ve had the fun of telling about it.
Back when I was writing Little House prequels, I used to have to turn in outlines for approval by the Laura Ingalls Wilder estate. Outlines are deadly to my writing process; once I’ve mapped a book out in that level of detail, the energy fizzles. It’s like I’ve had the fun of telling the story and now what’s left is the hard part, the actual writing.
So every time one of these outlines was approved, I’d sit down and write a totally different book. I never meant to; I would just start writing in the middle somewhere, searching for life, and suddenly the story would grow legs and skitter off in a different direction than the map I’d submitted.
And you know what? No one ever seemed to notice. When I turned in a manuscript, my editor edited the book she got, not the one she didn’t. I’m proud of those books and I’m happy they wouldn’t stay in their boxes. Some of the broad strokes do parallel the original outlines; there were parts of each story that I knew from the beginning I wanted to tell—the Roxbury hurricane; the story of Charlotte’s baby brother—but most of the everyday happenings in those stories grew as I wrote, not before.
I’ve been treading cautiously with my current novel-in-progress. With this one, I could see the broad outline very clearly from the first—danger! But as soon as I started writing, new developments elbowed in, pushing the early conception to the far corners of the page.
Which was a huge relief. I have to do this dance with any written work: know enough, but not too much. I remember once complaining to Scott that I had a paper due, and it seemed like a pointless exercise: “I know I can write it, and the professor knows I can write it, so why can’t we just leave it at that?” Heh. That was toward the end of a rigorous two years in graduate school and I was tired. Grinding out that paper felt rather, shall we say, academic.
Anyway, that’s where my thoughts have wandered on this cloudy afternoon. I didn’t plan this post in advance; I just searched “color” in my photo library and let my thoughts roam where they pleased.
Your photo project sounds like seeing carelessly…but then noticing. And something about that seems to relate to the novel writing too… I don’t want to say writing carelessly…
On January 11, 2023 at 5:03 pm
Anna Rose Johnson says:
I totally relate to your aversion to outlines! Planning out a whole book ahead of time seems to sap the energy out of the story, somehow.
I really need to read your Martha & Charlotte books!
On January 11, 2023 at 8:05 pm
Makes sense to me! We need to have a “then what happened?” even if we are telling the story ourselves. I like your secret photo project!
On January 12, 2023 at 4:52 am
I love your “secret art project”!
My daughter once almost took a zero on a big creative writing assignment because it involved outlining her story. “Moooom! I don’t write that way!” I told her no one is going to punish you if you don’t stick to your outline just put something down, and I was right. She completely changed the story. 🙂
On January 12, 2023 at 1:45 pm
You put this so well. I’m required sometimes to write a synopsis before I’m done drafting, and it’s just that – a story killer. Ugh. Trying to get ahead of the process, I’ve tried doing an outline before drafting – and EVERY time I end up somewhere else. I honestly don’t know why I bother.
But, there sometimes comes a point when I *need* to tell myself the story again… when I get stuck in the middle, I have to work my way around to remembering where all of the trailing threads are still waving… And then I am grateful to be the “listener” as well as the storyteller and remind myself of what I wanted to read.
On January 17, 2023 at 1:27 pm
I used to work with a very successful (and excellent) writer who simply could not write a synopsis ahead of time, even when it was required to sell a story. So he’d write the story and then, once he knew what the story was, he’d write and submit a synopsis. His stories always ended up getting bought.
On January 18, 2023 at 8:43 pm